Why do these charts all agree with each other?
Because they are the same data rendered differently. Every hours-per-pound figure, pull
temperature, USDA minimum, rest time, wood pairing, brine strength, yield fraction and
pellet burn rate on this site lives in a single file, and the
cook time calculator, the
per-cut pages and these charts all read from it. The fastest way to
lose a reader on a cooking site is for the calculator to say twelve hours and the chart on
the next page to say nine.
What that does not fix is variance in the real world. Hours per pound are planning estimates,
and a real cook moves by 25 percent or more with ambient temperature, wind, humidity, how
often the door opens, the individual animal, and whether the cut is wrapped. Thickness
matters more than weight: a thick twelve pound brisket takes longer than a flat fourteen
pound one, because heat travels inward from the surface and thickness sets the distance it
has to cover. Plan against the slow end and absorb the difference in the rest.
Use the charts to plan and the thermometer to finish. That split is the whole method, and
it is why the thermometer is the one purchase
this site refuses to let you compromise on.